Photodynamic Diagnosis-guided Transurethral Resection of Bladder Tumour in Participants with a First Suspected Diagnosis of Intermediate- or High-risk Non-muscle-invasive Bladder Cancer: Cost-effectiveness Analysis Alongside a Randomised Controlled Trial.
Date
2023-07-01Author
Yu, G
Rice, S
Heer, R
Lewis, R
Vadiveloo, T
Mariappan, P
Penegar, S
Clark, E
Tandogdu, Z
Hall, E
Vale, L
Type
Journal Article
Metadata
Show full item recordAbstract
BACKGROUND: Recurrence of non-muscle-invasive bladder cancer (NMIBC) is common after transurethral resection of bladder tumour (TURBT). Photodynamic diagnosis (PDD) may reduce recurrence. PDD uses a photosensitiser in the bladder that causes the tumour to fluoresce to guide resection. PDD provides better diagnostic accuracy and allows more complete tumour resection. OBJECTIVE: To estimate the economic efficiency of PDD-guided TURBT (PDD-TURBT) in comparison to white light-guided TURNT (WL-TURBT) in individuals with a suspected first diagnosis of NMIBC at intermediate or high risk of recurrence on the basis of routine visual assessment before being scheduled for TURBT. DESIGN SETTING AND PARTICIPANTS: This is a health economic evaluation alongside a pragmatic, open-label, parallel-group randomised trial from a societal perspective. A total of 493 participants (aged ≥16 yr) were randomly allocated to PDD-TURBT (n = 244) or WL-TURBT (n = 249) in 22 UK National Health Service hospitals. OUTCOME MEASUREMENTS AND STATISTICAL ANALYSIS: Cost effectiveness ratios were based on the use of health care resources associated with PDD-TURBT and WL-TURBT and quality-adjusted life years (QALYs) gained within the trial. Uncertainties in key parameters were assessed using sensitivity analyses. RESULTS AND LIMITATIONS: On the basis of the use of resources driven by the trial protocol, the incremental cost effectiveness of PDD-TURBT in comparison to WL-TURBT was not cost saving. At 3 yr, the total cost was £12 881 for PDD-TURBT and £12 005 for WL-TURBT. QALYs at three years were 2.087 for PDD-TURBT and 2.094 for WL-TURBT. The probability that PDD-TURBT is cost effective was never >30% above the range of societal cost-effectiveness thresholds. CONCLUSIONS: There was no evidence of a difference in either costs or QALYs over 3-yr follow-up between PDD-TURBT and WL-TURBT in individuals with suspected intermediate- or high-risk NMIBC. PDD-TURBT is not supported for the management of primary intermediate- or high-risk NMIBC. PATIENT SUMMARY: We assessed overall costs for two approaches for removal of bladder tumours in noninvasive cancer and measured quality-adjusted life years gained for each. We found that use of a photosensitiser in the bladder was not more cost effective than use of white light only during tumour removal.
Collections
Subject
Cost effectiveness
Hexvix
Non–muscle-invasive bladder cancer
Photodynamic diagnosis
Randomised trial
Surgery
Transurethral resection of bladder tumour
Urinary bladder neoplasms
Research team
Clin Trials & Stats Unit
Language
eng
Date accepted
2023-05-12
License start date
2023-07-01
Citation
European Urology Open Science, 2023, 53 pp. 67 - 77
Publisher
ELSEVIER
Except where otherwise noted, this item's license is described
as
https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/
Related items
Showing items related by title, author, creator and subject.
-
A practical approach to bladder preservation with hypofractionated radiotherapy for localised muscle-invasive bladder cancer.
Portner, R; Bajaj, A; Elumalai, T; Huddart, R; Murthy, V; et al. (ELSEVIER IRELAND LTD, 2021-08-19)Bladder preservation with trimodality treatment (TMT) is an alternative strategy to radical cystectomy (RC) for the management of localised muscle invasive bladder cancer (MIBC). TMT comprises of transurethral resection ... -
The Patient Deficit Model Overturned: a qualitative study of patients' perceptions of invitation to participate in a randomized controlled trial comparing selective bladder preservation against surgery in muscle invasive bladder cancer (SPARE, CRUK/07/011).
Moynihan, C; Lewis, R; Hall, E; Jones, E; Birtle, A; et al. (2012-11-29)Background Evidence suggests that poor recruitment into clinical trials rests on a patient 'deficit' model - an inability to comprehend trial processes. Poor communication has also been cited as a possible barrier to ... -
Molecular characterisation of muscle-invasive bladder cancer
Huddart, R; Tan, M (Institute of Cancer Research (University Of London), 2021-01-31)Background: Muscle-invasive bladder cancer (MIBC) is a heterogeneous disease with a poor prognosis. There is a clinical need for biomarkers in MIBC to guide treatment strategy for individual patients and improve outcomes. ...